Agenda and minutes

Venue: The Guildhall, High Street, Worcester WR1 2EY

Contact: Claire Chaplin, Democratic and Civic Services Manager - Tel: 01905 722005 

Media

Items
No. Item

18.

Apologies for Absence

Minutes:

None.

19.

Declarations of Interest

To receive any declarations of interest.

Minutes:

None.

20.

Public Participation

Up to a total of fifteen minutes can be allowed, each speaker being allocated  maximum of five minutes, for members of the public to present a petition, ask a question or comment on any matter on the Agenda or within the remit of the Council in accordance with Council Procedure Rule 10.

Minutes:

Francis Lankester spoke in respect of item 21 (Notice of Motion). In summary, he did not support the principle of Joint Leaders and he spoke in support of appointing a Leader and Deputy Leader.

21.

Notice of Motion pdf icon PDF 105 KB

To consider the following Notice of Motion submitted in accordance with Council Procedure Rule 8:

 

Changes to the Constitution and Appointments of Members

 

Proposed by: Councillor Denham

Additional documents:

Minutes:

The Council considered the following Notice of Motion, which had been submitted by Councillor Denham in accordance with Council Procedure Rule 8:

 

Changes to the Constitution and Appointments of Members

 

Following the elections on 4 May, the Council remains in a position of no overall control but the political composition of the Council has changed.

 

This Motion proposes certain amendments to the Constitution and consequential appointments of Members to reflect power-sharing arrangements which are considered appropriate to the resulting political composition of the Council.

 

The Group Leaders Protocol stipulates that it should be reviewed every time that the political balance of the Council changes.

 

This Motion also proposes the cessation of the Income Management Sub-Committee with immediate effect. This is proposed as a measure to reduce the administrative burden of the committee meeting cycle on councillors and officers.

 

Amendments

 

The amendments proposed to the Articles (Part 2), Group Leaders Protocol (Part 15)  and Responsibility for Functions (Part 3) are set out in the Appendices to this Motion. In summary the purpose of the amendments is:

 

(1)  To reinstate the principle, removed from the Constitution last May, that the Council should have a Leader and Deputy Leader, even in cases of no overall control. Accordingly, to remove the principle of Joint Leaders;

 

(2)  To ensure that, when there is no overall control, the Leader of the Council is appointed by Council from the largest Political Group;

 

(3)  To ensure that the Deputy Leader of the Council is appointed on a basis of a vote of Council, irrespective of whether there is political control or no overall control;

 

(4)  To delete references to the Income Management Sub-Committee in the Constitution’s Part 3 - Responsibility for Functions. Because it is a sub-committee of Policy and Resources Committee, there is no need to re-state its functions anywhere else in the Constitution.

 

Therefore, Council agrees that, with immediate effect:

 

1.   The Articles, Part 2 of the Constitution, be amended in the terms set out in Appendix 1, so as to remove the references to Joint Leaders and instead insert new references to the process for appointment of the Leader and Deputy Leader even in cases of no overall control;

 

2.   The Group Leaders Protocol, Part 15 of the Constitution, be amended in the terms set out in Appendix 2, to reflect the new political balance of the Council;

 

3.   The Responsibility for Functions, Part 3, be amended to remove all references to the Income Management Sub-Committee and its functions;

 

4.   The Monitoring Officer is instructed to make any consequential amendments to the Constitution to give effect to these decisions;

 

5.   The Council now proceed to make the requisite Member appointments in accordance with these new arrangements.

 

The proposer, Councillor Denham, spoke in support of the Motion. The Motion was seconded by Councillor Riaz, who also spoke. Members of the Council proceeded to debate the Motion.

 

In accordance with the rules set out in the Constitution, Councillor Bisset proposed the following amendment:

 

Delete items 1 and  ...  view the full minutes text for item 21.

22.

Appointment of Leader(s) of the Council

Minutes:

Consideration of the appointment of Leader(s) had been deferred at the Annual Council meeting. The Council proceeded to consider nominations for the appointment of two Joint Leaders, one from each of the two largest political groups, in accordance with the Constitution.

 

It was proposed by Councillor Riaz and seconded by Councillor Udall that Councillor Denham be nominated.

 

It was proposed by Councillor Laurenson and seconded by Councillor Piotrowski that Councillor Bisset be nominated.

 

There were no further nominations.

 

Upon being put to the vote it was

 

RESOLVED: That the Council agree that Councillors Denham and Bisset be elected as Joint Leaders of the Council.

 

The Mayor then proposed that the meeting be adjourned in accordance with the rules of debate for Council meetings as set out in the Constitution. The Council reconvened after an adjournment of 15 minutes.

23.

Political Balance on Committees and Sub-Committees

Minutes:

Consideration of this item had been deferred at the Annual Council meeting.

 

The Council received the report of the Monitoring Officer seeking Council’s approval of the allocation of seats between the political groups for the Municipal Year 2023/24. The Monitoring Officer clarified that the Income Management Sub-Committee would be included in the calculations, with a membership of 5. The allocation of seats was Labour 2, Green 2, Conservative 1.

 

It was proposed by Councillor Bisset and seconded by Councillor Piotrowski and on being put to the vote it was

 

RESOLVED: That the Council agree the allocation of seats between political groups for the Municipal Year 2023/24 as set out in Appendix 1 of the minutes.

24.

Appointment of Members to Committees and Sub-Committees and Appointment of Chairs and Vice-Chairs Etc.

Minutes:

Consideration of this item had been deferred at the Annual Council meeting.

 

The Council received details of nominations from Group Leaders for the appointment of Members to Policy Committees, Regulatory Committees, Joint Committees and Other Bodies. The Council considered the appointment of Chairs and Vice-Chairs to those Committees.

 

RESOLVED: That the Council approve the appointment of Members to Policy Committees, Regulatory Committees, Joint Committees and Other Bodies and the appointment of Chairs and Vice-Chairs as set out in Appendix 2 of the minutes.

25.

APPENDIX 1

Minutes:

APPENDIX 1 - POLITICAL BALANCE CALCULATIONS MAY 2023

 

 

Con

Lab

Green

Lib-Dem

Total

 

8

12

10

4

34

 

Places per Committee

Percentage share (rule D):

 

TOTAL

CON

LAB

GREEN

LIB-DEM

 

CON

LAB

GREEN

LIB-DEM

Total

Policy & Resources

13

3

4

4

2

13

23.1

30.8

30.8

15.4

100.0

P&GP

7

2

3

1

1

7

28.6

42.9

14.3

14.3

100.0

Income Management

5

1

2

2

0

5

20.0

40.0

40.0

0.0

100.0

Communities

11

3

4

3

1

11

27.3

36.4

27.3

9.1

100.0

Environment

11

2

4

4

1

11

18.2

36.4

36.4

9.1

100.0

Health & Wellbeing

11

2

4

4

1

11

18.2

36.4

36.4

9.1

100.0

Place & Econ. Dev.

11

3

4

3

1

11

27.3

36.4

27.3

9.1

100.0

Planning

11

3

4

3

1

11

27.3

36.4

27.3

9.1

100.0

Licencing

11

2

4

3

2

11

18.2

36.4

27.3

18.2

100.0

Audit & Governance

7

2

2

2

1

7

28.6

28.6

28.6

14.3

100.0

Standards

7

2

2

2

1

7

28.6

28.6

28.6

14.3

100.0

 

105

25

37

31

12

 

 

 

 

 

 

ACTUAL %

23.8

35.2

29.5

11.4

TARGET % (rule C)

23.5

35.3

29.4

11.8

23.5

35.3

29.4

11.8

DIFFERENCE

0.3

-0.1

0.1

-0.3

% difference

1%

0%

0%

-3%

 

26.

APPENDIX 2

Minutes:

APPENDIX 2 - WORCESTER CITY COUNCIL – APPOINTMENTS TO COMMITTEES AND SUB-COMMITTEES 2023/24

 

Policy Committees

 

POLICY & RESOURCES - MEMBERSHIP OF 13 – Meets 7 times per annum

 

 

LABOUR - 4

GREEN - 4

CONSERVATIVE - 3

 

LIBERAL DEMOCRAT - 2

Lynn Denham  - Vice Chair

Steve Cockeram

James Stanley – Chair

Mel Allcott

Jabba Riaz

Elena Round

Andy Roberts

Sarah Murray

Adrian Gregson

Tom Piotrowski

Stephen Hodgson

 

Robyn Norfolk

Marjory Bisset – Vice Chair

 

 

COMMUNITIES – MEMBERSHIP OF 11 – Meets 5 times per annum

 

 

LABOUR - 4

GREEN - 3

CONSERVATIVE - 3

 

LIBERAL DEMOCRAT - 1

Jabba Riaz - Chair

Tom Piotrowski

Alan Amos

Karen Lawrance

Matt Lamb

Hannah Cooper

Shafaz Ditta

 

Basharat Ali

Neil Laurenson – Vice Chair

Mohammad Altaf

 

Jill DeSayrah

 

 

 



ENVIRONMENT – MEMBERSHIP OF 11 - Meets 5 times per annum

 

 

LABOUR - 4

GREEN - 4

CONSERVATIVE - 2

 

LIBERAL DEMOCRAT - 1

Richard Udall

Marjory Bisset

Andy Roberts

Jessie Jagger

Atif Sadiq

Hannah Cooper

Owen Cleary

 

Sue Smith

Andrew Cross

 

 

Zoe Cookson – Vice Chair

Karen Lewing – Chair

 

 


 


HEALTH AND WELLBEING – MEMBERSHIP OF 11 - Meets 5 times per annum

 

 

LABOUR - 4

GREEN - 4

CONSERVATIVE - 2

 

LIBERAL DEMOCRAT - 1

Lynn Denham - Chair

Neil Laurenson

Stephen Hodgson – Vice Chair

Sarah Murray

Richard Udall

Louis Stephen

Shafaz Ditta

 

Atif Sadiq

Steve Cockeram

 

 

Basharat Ali

Tor Pingree

 

 

PLACE & ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT– MEMBERSHIP OF 11 - Meets 5 times per annum

 

 

LABOUR - 4

GREEN - 3

CONSERVATIVE - 3

 

LIBERAL DEMOCRAT - 1

Adrian Gregson

Hannah Cooper

James Stanley

Jessie Jagger

Jabba Riaz

Elena Round

Owen Cleary – Vice Chair

 

Robyn Norfolk - Chair

Karen Lewing

Simon Geraghty

 

Jill DeSayrah 

 

 

 

INCOME MANAGEMENT SUB – MEMBERSHIP OF 5 – Meets 5 times per annum

Adrian Gregson

Elena Round

James Stanley - Chair

 

Jabba Riaz – Vice Chair

Tom Piotrowski

 

 


PERSONNEL & GENERAL PURPOSES SUB – MEMBERSHIP OF 7 – Meets 4 times per annum

 

LABOUR - 3

GREEN - 1

CONSERVATIVE - 2

 

LIBERAL DEMOCRAT - 1

Lynn Denham

Steve Cockeram – Chair

James Stanley – Vice Chair

Sarah Murray

Jabba Riaz

 

Simon Geraghty

 

Zoe Cookson

 

 

 


 

Regulatory Committees

 

PLANNING - MEMBERSHIP OF 11 – Meets 12 times per annum

 

 

LABOUR - 4

GREEN - 3

CONSERVATIVE - 3

 

LIBERAL DEMOCRAT - 1

Pat Agar  - Vice Chair

Karen Lewing – Chair

Alan Amos

Mel Allcott

Richard Udall

Andrew Cross

Shafaz Ditta

 

Jill DeSayrah

Elena Round

Owen Cleary

 

Sue Smith

 

 

 

LICENSING & ENVIRONMENTAL HEALTH – MEMBERSHIP OF 11 – Meets 4 times per annum; LICENSING SUB-COMMITTEE – Meets 12 times per annum

 

LABOUR - 4

GREEN - 3

CONSERVATIVE - 2

 

LIBERAL DEMOCRAT - 2

Richard Udall - Chair

Louis Stephen

Stephen Hodgson

Mel Allcott – Vice Chair

Pat Agar

Andrew Cross

James Stanley

Karen Lawrance

Robyn Norfolk

Tor Pingree

 

 

Sue Smith

 

 

 

AUDIT & GOVERNANCE – MEMBERSHIP OF 7  - Meets 4 times per annum

 

LABOUR - 2

GREEN - 2

CONSERVATIVE - 2

 

LIBERAL DEMOCRAT - 1

Matt Lamb

Tom Piotrowski – Vice  ...  view the full minutes text for item 26.